Most brand websites don’t have a traffic problem. They have a leak problem.
You publish blogs, run campaigns, and invest in design and content. Yet traffic stays flat, and nobody can say why. Most of the time, the answer isn’t in your content at all. It’s hiding underneath: broken pages, wrong redirects, and URLs that Google was never allowed to read.
We see this on almost every brand website we audit at DigiChefs. The owner thinks they need more content or a bigger ad budget. Then we run one crawl and find that a lot of their hard work is already there, just leaking through technical gaps.
The good news is that you don’t need five expensive tools to find these gaps. A Screaming Frog crawl and Google Search Console show you most of what matters. And you don’t need to be a developer to understand the results.
Here are the 7 checks we run first on a brand website, why each one affects your traffic, and how we fix it.
Why we use Screaming Frog
It crawls your website the way Google does and lists every URL in one place: status, title, canonical, links, and images. The free version handles 500 URLs, and a paid licence covers bigger sites. That is a small cost next to the monthly subscription of most audit tools. This is the real benefit of a Screaming Frog SEO audit: you see your actual problems, not a generic score.
1. Broken pages and server errors
Open the Response Codes tab and filter for 4xx and 5xx errors. Then click each URL and check Inlinks, which shows every page still linking to it.
Why it matters: A visitor who lands on a dead page leaves straight away, and that pushes your bounce rate up. It also wastes the link value that other pages and websites are sending to it. Think of every broken page as a shop door that’s locked while customers stand outside.
The fix: Redirect it to the closest relevant page, or bring the page back. Then update the internal links so they stop pointing to the old URL. Start with broken pages that have the most inlinks, because those are hurting you the most.
2. Redirect chains
Go to Reports > Redirects > Redirect Chains. A chain looks like Page A to B to C to D. It usually appears after a redesign, a move to HTTPS or a domain change, when each new developer adds one more redirect on top of the last.
Why it matters: Every extra hop slows the page down and makes Google’s job harder. On mobile, where connections are slower, those extra seconds are exactly when people give up. Long chains and loops can also stop a page from being crawled properly at all.
The fix: Point Page A directly to the final page. Aim for one hop only. It’s a small fix, but it’s one of the quickest speed wins we see.
3. Pages Google can’t index
Check the Indexability column. Look for “Noindex”, “Canonicalised” or “Blocked by robots.txt” on pages that should rank, like your service pages, product pages and best blogs.
Why it matters: One stray noindex tag, left over from a staging site, can hide a money page for months. Nobody notices because the page looks perfect when you open it. Meanwhile, Google quietly leaves it out, and your competitors take the traffic.
The fix: Remove the tag or correct the canonical. Then submit the page in Google Search Console so it’s picked up faster. We always do this check early, because there’s no point polishing a page Google can’t see.
4. Orphan pages and weak internal links
Connect your sitemap and Google Search Console to the crawl. Pages that are in the sitemap but have no links pointing to them are called orphan pages. Also check Crawl Depth. Important pages more than 3 clicks from the homepage get less attention from both Google and visitors.
Why it matters: Internal linking is one of the cheapest traffic wins there is. You already own the pages. You just need to connect them. This gets harder as sites grow, and it’s the first thing we look at when a client has thousands of URLs. Large catalogues and multi-location sites need the kind of structure our enterprise SEO services are built around.
The fix: Add links from relevant blogs and pages, using clear anchor text that says what the next page is about. Don’t use “click here”.
5. Titles, meta descriptions and H1s
Open the Page Titles and Meta Description tabs. Filter for missing, duplicate, and too-long ones, then check that every page has one clear H1.
Why it matters: Rankings get you seen, but titles get you clicked. Combine the crawl with Search Console and look for pages with plenty of impressions but few clicks. Those pages are already ranking; they’re just not convincing anyone. A better title can lift traffic without a single new ranking.
The fix: Rewrite them the way a person would want to read them. Put the main keyword near the start, say what the reader gets, and keep it short enough not to be cut off. Test the rewritten ones for a month and see which win.
6. Thin and duplicate content
Check the word counts, and turn on Near Duplicates in the crawl settings. Look for several pages that say almost the same thing, like old location pages or product pages with copied descriptions.
Why it matters: When your own pages compete with each other, none of them rank well. Google has to guess which one to show, and it often guesses wrong. Thin pages also make visitors leave fast, because there’s nothing useful on them.
The fix: Merge them into one stronger page, or make each one clearly different. Don’t add words for the sake of length. If you’re not sure which pages to merge and which to keep, a technical SEO consultant can save you from deleting a page that was quietly earning traffic.
7. Heavy images and slow pages
Open the Images tab and sort by file size. Then connect the PageSpeed Insights API inside Screaming Frog, so you get speed scores for every URL in one report.
Why it matters: Most of your visitors are on mobile, and they won’t wait for a slow page. Large images are the most common reason pages feel slow, and they’re easy to miss because the site looks fine on a fast office connection. Speed affects rankings, but it affects bounce rate and sales even more.
The fix: Compress the images, use modern formats like WebP, and lazy-load images below the fold. Then re-crawl to check that the biggest files are gone. This one is a favourite with developers, because it’s clear and quick.
What happens after the crawl?
A crawl gives you thousands of rows. That is not an audit. The real work is deciding what to fix first.
We sort every issue by impact. Problems on pages that bring leads or sales come first, and cosmetic warnings come last. That way, your team fixes ten things that matter instead of a hundred that don’t. Use these seven points as your starting SEO audit checklist, and you’ll already be ahead of most websites.
Want us to find where your website is leaking?
If you’re comparing an SEO audit company, ask one question: will I get a prioritised plan, or just a PDF of errors?
Our technical SEO audit services give you the plan, with clear fixes your developers can start on straight away. Tell us your website, and we’ll show you what’s holding your traffic back.